Journal of China in Global and Comparative Perspectives

Abstract: As is well known, Max Weber’s three-volume Economic Ethics of the World Religions on China, India and ancient Israel yields ‘contrast case’ analyses that isolate the uniqueness of ‘Western’ and ‘modern Western’ rationalism. Less well known is the sociology of civilizations contained in these volumes and in Economy and Society. This study identifies five themes that, taken in combination, are central to this project. Uniquely, Weber’s approach to the study of civilizations stresses a) the researcher’s capacity to understand the subjective meaning of action by persons in groups quite different from those familiar in the modern West, b) the constitution of the distinct ‘rationalisms’ of varying civilizations past and present, and c) the capacity of values to ‘rationalize’ action beyond utilitarian calculations. Comprehension of each civilization on its own terms comes here to the forefront, as does the unusually broad – civilizational – range of Weber’s sociology.

Keywords: Max Weber, Civilizations, Subjective meaning, Value-rationalization